With most of the A's top prospects playing at the highest the level of the system for Triple-A Nashville this season, I've been thinking about what a young A's team might look like if the front office decides to give their top young prospects a shot on the major league squad next year. So this week I took the opportunity to examine what a team full of young prospects might look like on my Athletics Farm site, and I thought I'd also take the opportunity to share it here on Athletics Nation. It's also worth noting that one of the key prospects mentioned below, catcher Bruce Maxwell, just landed on the disabled list at Nashville this week with an oblique injury…
Whatever happens with the A's before the start of next season, one thing is certain – with many of the team's current everyday players set to become free agents in the offseason, there's bound to be plenty of turnover on the 25-man roster.
Center fielder Rajai Davis, first baseman Yonder Alonso, third baseman Trevor Plouffe, current shortstop Adam Rosales, as well as reliever John Axford, are all set to hit the free agent market in the offseason, and second baseman Jed Lowrie has a team option for 2018 and seems unlikely to return. Of course, most of these potential free agents are likely to be traded before the season is through but, one way or another, they're all likely to be long-gone by the time 2018 rolls around.
The only regular position players in the starting lineup who are currently under team control for 2018 are outfielders Khris Davis and Matt Joyce, catcher Stephen Vogt, first baseman/designated hitter Ryon Healy and shortstop Marcus Semien, who will reclaim his starting shortstop role once he returns from the disabled list. Backup catcher Josh Phegley, utility infielder Chad Pinder and reserve outfielders Mark Canha and Jake Smolinski will also remain under team control for 2018. And the entire pitching staff, with the exception of Axford, will still be under control next year as well.
Of course, no one is ever certain what the A's will do in the offseason, but it does seem as though the front office has structured this team to be ready for a big youth infusion next season – which could work well with the team's stated intention of announcing plans for a new stadium before the end of the year.
So, disregarding any potential trades or free agent signings, let's just assume that the A's do decide to move forward with a full-on youth movement next season, stocking the roster with as many prospects as possible who are currently in the team's minor league system. No one is saying that they will, or that they should, but just for the fun of it, let's take a look at what a young, prospect-laden A's team could potentially look like in 2018.
As previously mentioned, the pitching staff is already full of fairly young arms under team control, so any big changes would primarily involve position players, which is what I'll mainly focus on here, though I will briefly touch on 2018's potential pitching staff as well. It's worth noting that every single position player proposed below for a potential prospect-laden A's roster is currently age 29 or under, with Khris Davis the only potential everyday.player currently over the age of 26.
The team's current catching corps is set to be under team control for next year. 32-year-old Stephen Vogt is earning $2.965 million this season and will be eligible for arbitration for the second time in the offseason, while 29-year-old Josh Phegley is earning just $545,000 this year and will be arbitration-eligible for the first time this offseason. With Vogt struggling so far this season and set to receive a raise through the arbitration system next year, this looks like an obvious spot to make a move to get younger. 26-year-old catcher Bruce Maxwell seems to have mastered Triple-A at this point, with a career slash line of .318/.386/.527 in the Pacific Coast League. And he's looked fairly solid both at the plate and behind the plate during his 42 major league games for the A's last year and this year. If the team does decide to put the left-handed-hitting Maxwell behind the dish next season, then it would make plenty of sense to keep Phegley around as his right-handed-hitting counterpart, and to try to make a deal to trade the popular Vogt either this summer or in the offseason to a club that's looking for a little veteran catching help.
When we look at the A's outfield picture for 2018, two things seem fairly certain: one Davis will stay and one Davis will go. 29-year-old left fielder Khris Davis, who's hit 55 home runs since joining the A's last season, is clearly the best-hitting outfielder on the A's roster and seems likely to stick around. Davis is under team control for two more seasons, and he could serve as the most veteran presence on a young A's squad next year while manning left field and holding down the cleanup spot. But 36-year-old center fielder Rajai Davis was always intended to serve as a one-year rental and is expected to depart via free agency in the offseason. One of last year's other free agent signings, 32-year-old right fielder Matt Joyce, was signed to a two-year deal but has severely under-performed so far for the A's. With one year left on his contract after this season, the team could try to foist him off on a contending club looking for a veteran left-handed bat, even if it means having to eat part of his deal. If the A's do decide to go with a youth movement next year, there really won't be much room on the roster for an under-achieving veteran outfielder with sub-par defensive skills. The A's could replace Joyce in right field with 23-year-old slugger Matt Olson, who currently has 10 home runs, a .368 on-base percentage and a .552 slugging percentage for the Sounds while also leading the team with 20 walks. Olson has long been looked at as one of the top power-hitting prospects in the system and, though he's mainly been playing first base for Nashville this season, he primarily played right field last year at Triple-A, has appeared at the position in half of his major league games, and has looked solid as a corner outfielder, where his strong arm can come in handy. Olson would immediately represent a defensive upgrade in the outfield and, potentially, an offensive one as well. When it comes to replacing Rajai in center, finding a successor in the A's system could be tough since the A's organization is sorely lacking in true center fielders, but there is one possible replacement who might be worth taking a chance on, and that's Jaycob Brugman. Many in the A's front office seem to feel that the 25-year-old is better-suited to serve as a part-time center fielder and really view him as more of a corner outfielder. And while he may not have the quickness and the range that one would ideally like to see in a true center fielder, it's been a while since the A's have had the luxury of having a true center fielder, and Brugman has shown a propensity for out-performing expectations at every level. He's also experienced, having played more games in center field than at any other position in his minor league career. And while appearing in 155 games in center, Brugman has made just 2 errors at the position. Then there's the fact that, while serving as the Sounds' primary leadoff hitter, he's boasting a .364/.432/.439 slash line this season since returning from the disabled list earlier this month. The former 17th-round draft pick has over-achieved at every minor league level, and he could do the same at the major league level as the A's center fielder in 2018. It's worth noting that Brugman and Olson are both left-handed hitters, but 28-year-old right-handed-hitting outfielders Mark Canha and Jake Smolinski both remain under team control for another few years and could be available to serve as platoon partners if needed.
The A's could be due for the biggest turnover in the infield next year. 30-year-old first baseman Yonder Alonso, 30-year-old third baseman Trevor Plouffe, and 34-year-old utility infielder Adam Rosales are all expected to depart via free agency after the season, if they're not dealt before then, while 33-year-old second baseman Jed Lowrie's contract has a club option for 2018, which essentially puts him in the same boat as the rest. The only starting infielder expected to return is 26-year-old shortstop Marcus Semien, who remains under team control through 2020. Fortunately, the A's do have some talented young players to put around him in the infield, including top prospects Matt Chapman and Franklin Barreto as well as a number of other promising young players. The 24-year-old Chapman has been the A's top third base prospect since the day the team made him its top draft pick in June of 2014. He hit 23 home runs in just 304 at-bats for Stockton in 2015, mashed 36 between Midland and Nashville last year, and has hit 8 in just 97 at-bats while boasting a .536 slugging percentage so far this season for the Sounds. And to top it off, Chapman is also considered a top defender at the hot corner with an elite throwing arm. Widely considered to be the A's top hitting prospect, Barreto just turned 21 a few months ago, but he's already been tearing it up at Triple-A this year, putting up an impressive .311/.361/.491 slash line for the Sounds so far this season. Though Barreto has spent most of his time at the shortstop position, he's also seen some time at second base, and many in the A's front office have openly talked about the likelihood of him having to make the move to the other side of the bag, where the A's are likely to soon have an opening. 25-year-old infielder Ryon Healy debuted with a bang for Oakland last season, posting a .305/.337/.524 slash line for the A's. He's been hitting at a more average pace so far this season while primarily serving in the designated hitter role, but Healy still holds plenty of promise. And given the chance to move out of the DH spot and play every day in the field at first base for the A's in 2018 could be just what he needs to get back on track and really show what he can do. And speaking of designated hitters, 23-year-old slugger Renato Nunez has spent most of his minor league career playing third base, but since Matt Chapman has returned to health at Nashville, Nunez has been spending most of his time alternating between left field and the designated hitter spot for the Sounds. Nunez's power has always been real, and he currently leads his team in home runs with 12 and in doubles with 10 while sporting a .550 slugging percentage, and he even managed to hit a ball clear out of First Tennessee Park in last Thursday's game. With his power bat and his defensive deficiencies, Nunez seems perfectly-suited to serve in the designated hitter role. And in a limited sample so far this season, 25-year-old infielder Chad Pinder has looked like one of the A's best hitters. He's gotten starts at shortstop, at second base, in the outfield and as the designated hitter so far for the A's, and he's also spent time at third base in college and in the minors. Pinder's versatility could make him well-suited for a super-utility role, spelling Barreto at second, Semien at short and Chapman at third, while also filling in in the outfield and as well as in the designated hitter spot. We all know how much the A's value versatility, and Pinder's positional flexibility could make him a valuable piece for a young A's team in 2018.
As mentioned earlier, the major turnover for the A's next year is likely to be on the position-player front, and that's primarily because Oakland's pitching staff is already full of fairly young arms who will be under team control for years to come. The organization currently has a dozen starting pitchers at the major league or Triple-A level who will all still be in their 20's next year and will remain under team control for multiple years, with Sonny Gray the first to be eligible for free agency after the 2019 season. These pitchers (with their current ages in parentheses) include: Sonny Gray (27), Kendall Graveman (26), Sean Manaea (25), Andrew Triggs (28), Jesse Hahn (27), Jharel Cotton (25), Chris Bassitt (28), Daniel Mengden (24), Raul Alcantara (24), Daniel Gossett (24), Paul Blackburn (23) and Zach Neal (28). That represents a fair number of fairly decent young arms who still have the potential to get much better and will remain under control for years to come. That's not even mentioning all the talented young arms the A's currently have below the Triple-A level, including 24-year-old RHP Corey Walter and 21-year-old RHP Grant Holmes at Midland, and 22-year-old LHP A.J. Puk and 22-year-old RHP Logan Shore at Stockton. That should give the A's plenty of pitching options to choose from in 2018 and beyond. As for the bullpen, it looks like that's where most of the veterans may be found for the 2018 A's. 34-year-old RHP John Axford is the only reliever eligible for free agency in the offseason, which means that most members of the A's bullpen could potentially return, including RHPs Ryan Madson, Santiago Casilla, Liam Hendriks, Ryan Dull and Frankie Montas, along with LHPs Sean Doolittle and Daniel Coulombe, all of whom remain under team control for 2018. Of course, 25-year-old RHP Bobby Wahl and 29-year-old RHP Josh Smith, who are both currently auditioning for the A's, could also be options, as could 26-year-old RHP Tucker Healy, who's currently sporting a 1.13 ERA for Nashville.
As mentioned earlier, this isn't necessarily a prescription, but just a look at what could happen if they A's do decide to move forward with a full-on youth movement next season. Of course, if the team does decide to deal potential free agents like Alonso, Plouffe, Lowrie, Rosales, Rajai Davis and Axford, or possibly even veterans like Vogt and Joyce, before the season's through, that could net a number of new prospects in return who could potentially fill even more holes on a talented young A's team next year. But, whatever happens, it's certain that there will be a lot of new faces on the 2018 A's, and most likely, many of them will be much younger faces.
Visit Athletics Farm for updates on the A’s minor league teams and all the top prospects down on the farm.