clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

All Star Selection: Who's Yours?

New, 149 comments

Join us for the SB Nation Bay Area Meet-up; selected drinks provided by Crown Royal. Details and RSVP link here.

So as we head into the halfway point of the season, it's clear that it's not going to be a year with a McGwire/Canseco/Vida Blue/Eck/Rickey heading to the All-Star game in Anaheim. It's going to be a year when we only get a representative because we have to have one.

I think it's safe to say there will only be one. But who will it be?

I have narrowed the field to five candidates:

Trevor Cahill

Even though I picked Gonzalez over Cahill to start the season, there is no doubt that Cahill has been the best starter on the team (and it's not because he's one of the only pitchers still standing). He's been genuinely fantastic. Gonzalez's numbers aren't bad, but if a starting pitcher is going, it should be Cahill with his 7-2, 2.88 ERA, 1.08 WHIP, 24/52 BB/K ratio.

Andrew Bailey

He's only recorded 15 saves (in only 18 chances), but his ERA is 1.69 and his WHIP is 0.97. Numbers don't come much lower than those.

Kurt Suzuki

He's missed some time, but has still managed to hit 10 homeruns and collect 25 RBI, while batting .267 and slugging .451. It's not great, but it might be better than the rest of the pack, and he certainly has the edge going in as a catcher.

Kevin Kouzmanoff

The dark horse choice for the A's would be the newcomer Kouz, who is quietly batting .280 with 8 HR and 39 RBI. His power numbers are lower than Suzuki's and his OPS is much lower than Barton's, so it is unlikely that he would beat out the others, but I gave him a nod.

Daric Barton

Batting .280 with 20 doubles and 30 RBI, and sporting an OPS of .795, Barton should be a serious contender for the lone A's All-Star spot. Despite the maddening sacrifice bunts, Barton has quietly put together a solid season for himself.

So...who goes? (And I recognize that the choice may come down to what position the AL needs to fill.)

What are your thoughts on the All Star game? Is anyone attending in person? Do you think there should be at least one rep from each team? Do you think there should be a limit on how many players from one team can go? How do you feel about the game?


Current Series

Athletics lead the series 1-0

Tue 06/29 WP: Vin Mazzaro (3 - 2)
SV: Andrew Bailey
LP: Brian Matusz (2 - 9)
4 - 2 win

Oakland Athletics
@ Baltimore Orioles

Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010, 4:05 PM PDT
Oriole Park at Camden Yards

Ben Sheets vs Kevin Millwood

Clear. Winds blowing in from left field at 10-15 m.p.h. Game time temperature around 80.

Complete Coverage >

Thu 07/01 4:05 PM PDT