Krueger + 2 Fired
This will hit the AP wire shortly:
http://www.knbr.com/homestory/statement.html
Apparently, earlier this morning, the Morning Show made a comedy act out of Felipe Alou's comments on ESPN's Outside the Lines.
Bob Agnew, Tony Rhein, and Larry Kreuger are no longer at KNBR effective tomorrow.
Couple of questions:
1- Does Krueger deserve to be fired?
2- Is the comedy act just an excuse for the station to bend to the hopes of other parties that Krueger be fired?
3- Can you ever in your wildest dreams imagine Marty Lurie dragging the team and the fans into such a situation?
Happy to be an A's fan, and glad that we aren't currently embroiled in a similar situation.
173 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Wow.
Rhein just got married
Wow
by southofcruiseamerica on Aug 9, 2005 11:48 PM PDT reply actions
Wow
also
They don't have a problem
by southofcruiseamerica on Aug 10, 2005 12:07 AM PDT up reply actions
Krueger Satan?
by 2xr on Aug 10, 2005 2:25 PM PDT up reply actions
re
I'm hoping Barbieri is next...
Re: Happy to be an A's fan...
But, I wonder who was the guy with Quaker Oats for brains that put the A's on a friggn' Superstition Station? ;-)
I'd be happier if the A's had their own radio station, where they could fire those who disagreed with them. Does that make me not a libertarian? Nah... private muscle is okay, it's the state that sucks.
That's Just B.S...
Every host who has supported Larry (not his comment, but the man himself) on the air over the last few days, including Gary, Rick, Rod, and Ralph, should all resign.
My thoughts exactly
Gary was so eloquent in his defense of Kruger, saying passionately, "If it happens again, get him the hell out of here!" But saying that Kruger had been there too long not to have earned a second chance. I'm scared to listen to Gary today--I think he might have to call in depressed. Or angry. What the hell is this world coming to?
by rubin sierra on Aug 10, 2005 8:30 AM PDT up reply actions
Gary's defense was lame
The other guys were fired because they made up voice parody of Alou saying "Satan" and marrying it to South Park audio. Too much, I guess. Don't these guys like high-paying jobs?
Krueger's defense by Radnich was, "Hey, He has a wife and kids, and one on the way." Guess what, that is a no-no in Human Relations for about 20-30 YEARS... you cannot judge performance by external factors, just like you cannot interview someone for a job and say, "Are you planning on getting pregnant?
Plain and simple, Krueger has "Rome Envy" and thinks blasting people gets fans excited. That's why I don't listen to Krueger. Nothin' to say I couldn't hear at a typical bar, plus I might get a free beer for listenin'.
Radnich makes $1 mill a year. Krueger make maybe a third. So let him live in Pittsburg. It's not as if we're sending him to Iraq!
by Ducts on the Pawn on Aug 10, 2005 8:10 PM PDT up reply actions
I honestly believe this is an over-reaction
Krueger screwed up. But to drag down other colleagues with successful track records is overkill. It's more likely this was the "last straw" after Jon London's "Not Just Sports Show" was such a disaster too - could be other issues in play.
Also - I think Alou's role is not angelic. If Macha hated Extra Innings with Robert Buan and Buan said he was "old", would that raise a call that he was agist, and should lose his job? How persistent would Macha be in his defense?
I have to side with the radio personalities here - what a bunch of media over-reaction hoo ha.
Which makes me wonder if the coach was
What a tangled web...
by A s Eh on Aug 10, 2005 7:05 AM PDT up reply actions
Wow...
Ratto was more correct than I imagined.
Krueger's verbal brainfart left the station in an untenable position. I have no idea about the morning show, or what they did. KNBR's Giant cheerleading drives me nuts, but now the station's shaky credibility really takes a hit.
Who will dare criticize the Giants now?
And if no one does, because it gets you fired, how will anyone - even Giants fans - take them seriously?
I am surprised that cooler heads didn't prevail. But it seems the Giants will brook no dissent on their station.
Glenn Dickey's thoughts
http://www.glenndickey.com/_gd.php?page=current
Regardless, it's an interesting read.
SF Chron's story...
Why is no one talking about how Felipe has offended millions in the Satan-worshipping community?
"This messenger of Satan?"
It probably wasn't a smart move for people wanting to keep their jobs, but still...
Heh. Radnich says the Giants had nothing to do with the Tuesday Night Massacre.
Like I said above, KNBR has a serious credibility problem.
And, Radnich...
by FoolshGame22 on Aug 10, 2005 12:57 AM PDT up reply actions
Yep ...
Who is the "real" sinner? The talking head of Satan, who, in a moment of sheer idiocy, shoots himself in the career? Or the proud man, that refuses an apology?
Do the math:
Are there really hundreds of millions of Caribbeans?
by angus hanger on Aug 10, 2005 7:26 AM PDT up reply actions
I'm sure there are hundreds of millions
by gigglingone on Aug 10, 2005 10:03 AM PDT up reply actions
Ah, ah ... be nice ...
- I was born and raised in Florida ... specifically Orlando and Miami.
- While there may be persons of Carribean descent that could reach that total, there is simply are not enough population currently living, in that region, to arrive at that figure, whether they are incensed or otherwise ...
- I am half american indian, and have seen racism displayed first hand. I am not buying the race card played.
- The statement made was to engage thinking, not arguement.
by angus hanger on Aug 10, 2005 4:18 PM PDT up reply actions
we'll see today
As to the assertion that the giants didn't want Krueger fired, I don't buy that. There were some really pissed off people over at SBC and this happened pretty quickly so I'm guessing KNBR did this to placate the giants. The Satan sendup was just the final straw which started things early. Krueger was probably gone next Monday at 7:00 p.m. when his suspension was over. I'm a bit sad as Larry had a pretty listenable show and got good guests. Even though I didn't always agree with him he put together a good show and spent time on it. KNBR is definitely under the giants thumb like Ratto said.
Krueger was all set to return to work
I agree!
Krueger is just another victim
The freakin national media is to be blamed for this travesty also. I try to watch highlights of the A's game against the Royals and Sportscenter made the Krueger comments its top story.
All this bad publicity made it clear that heads were going to roll and it's just sad that one of KNBR's better talkshow host had to go.
by RockLee on Aug 10, 2005 12:55 AM PDT reply actions
Sheesh
It's amazing to me that a mass media that won't take the time to think anything through beyond the surface 99% of the time WILL take the time to dissect a hot cereal reference and turn it into veritable KKK propoganda.
Did it ever occur to anyone that Cream of Wheat just happens to be very MUSHY thus the awkward elegance of the metaphor?
It's been reported that,
So this leaves the "Caribbean" comment as the bone of contention. What if Krueger had said "brain-dead Bahamian hitters?" Ah, the fine nuances.
Re last night's game, can I go off on "brain-dead Dakotan 2nd basemen, bungling double-play balls" without getting banned?
Only if Ellis were a person of color, apparently.
(Note: I love Ellis.)
by Checkswing HR on Aug 10, 2005 11:03 AM PDT up reply actions
Ahhh
I dunno. The line on offensive moniker is so personal. Thus the debate. But I still don't think his comments were worthy of a firing.
Where will Krueger land on his feet?
Also, didn't Knapp have a column saying how Alou handled this situation with dignity yesterday? That must have been written before the Satan comments were made.
What's up
i feel sorry for krueger
that is absolutely ridiculous.
Krueger
The Giant's may feel good about the firings
Shake up or mediocrity to reign?
by A s Eh on Aug 10, 2005 7:02 AM PDT reply actions
Bottom line: Alou wasn't backing down
KNBR has been the PR arm of the Giants for over 25 years, and this is part of the "deal with the devil" they've made.
But if the Giants think KNBR will bring back Frank Dill and Mike Cleary they have another thing coming.
by Rob @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 7:19 AM PDT reply actions
I think that they were really fired for...
Urban?
by Parklife on Aug 10, 2005 8:11 AM PDT reply actions
Urban would quit his MLB.com
by Checkswing HR on Aug 10, 2005 11:05 AM PDT up reply actions
Krueger got EXACTLY what he deserved
Felipe's 100% right to want his head on a platter. I'm happy to see a piece of crap like Krueger on the soup line.
If he said..
I agree with you about Krueger
But we don't know what was happening there
Agnew and Rhein made a poor judgement call. To put together a piece ridiculing Alou when the station is in the midst of all this is not a smart idea. And again, we have no idea what the KNBR staff was told they should and should not do while all of this is going on...
by gigglingone on Aug 10, 2005 10:00 AM PDT up reply actions
I disagree completely
This really seems to me like a huge overreaction by well-intentioned, but overly-sensitive people.
by LD on Aug 10, 2005 4:54 PM PDT up reply actions
You know, this really pisses me off
I hope they're happy. Now three people who, unlike them, actually rely on their paycheck to live, are kicked out onto the street--one, in Tony Rhein, who just got married, and whom I doubt very much made the big bucks. The Giants should be ashamed of themselves.
Edit to say two
KNBR Right to Fire Krueger and Agnew
Now everybody can make a mistake and KNBR was right for initially giving Krueger a 7 day suspension. But Krueger, having opened the wound, must have had a death wish by rubbing dirt in it with his satire coming on the first day back at the job. And Agnew was doubtless fired because he approved Krueger's inclusion of the South Park "satanic" sound bites.
A few words about Bob Agnew. He was general manager at KCBS when I wrote news for that station in 1980. Agnew was feared and hated by EVERYONE in the newsroom. He was called Bob Dogdoo because he was like a lamebrained fraternity boy. Worst of all, he knew nothing about news and won't the newsroom to focus upon gossip and sensation. Most of us refused.Agnew "resigned" from the station in 1982 and turned to sports broadcasting in Philly for awhile until KNBR hired him.
In the newsroom and in numerous comments, Agnew expressed nothing but contempt for minorities and women, so I can see this carrying over into his approval of the Krueger "satire". Among KNBR's rank and file, I have little doubt that his firing was applauded...
by reztips on Aug 10, 2005 9:18 AM PDT reply actions
Krueger wasn't responsible for the satire
The insider's perspective on Agnew helps some. I still don't think that mocking Alou's ricidulous Satan comments is much of an offense, but someone with that much experience probably should have known better than to allow the would to be salted.
Firing Tony Rhein is just plain weak.
You can't be serious!!!
Krueger made a mistake that I'm sure he'll never make again. I don't have a problem with him being punished, but Alou hasn't handled this situation with any class or dignity in my opinion.
Racism of the worst order??
by OaktownPower on Aug 10, 2005 3:12 PM PDT up reply actions
Error
by reztips on Aug 10, 2005 9:22 AM PDT reply actions
I lost a lot of respect
For an "old-school" manager to accuse Larry Krueger of prejudice is the pot calling the kettle, er...what PC word can I use that won't get me fired?
When Alou and his fellow "good ol' boys" cronies show tolerance for female umpires and openly gay athletes, then we'll talk. Until then, as far as I'm concerned, Alou is nothing more than an overrated manager who communicates through silence, is "too proud" to accept an apology (or admit mistakes), overmanages and exhausts his bullpen, and wants to take out a lousy season on a scapegoat.
That's not a workable standard
But beyond that, the standard of waiting to take action against an offender until others similarly get in line is just silly. Do we wait to punish thieves because cops are also stealing stuff from the evidence room? Of course not - we look to punish them both.
Whether or not Alou is a good baseball manager is irrelevant to this discussion.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 10:17 AM PDT up reply actions
Sort of true
Taking away someone's livelihood over something they've acknowledged as a mistake, which they've made every effort to remedy, is harsh. And I have no respect for Felipe driving the nails in the coffin by ridculously likening Krueger to Satan.
Female umpires and gay ballplayers
Alou and every baseball player who have expressed outrage over Krueger's comments need to be asked that question.
Part of me understands Alou's indignation. He's undoubtedly put up with worse crap during his career, and doesn't want to hear any of it - nor does he want to hear some apology.
But somebody needed to calm Alou down, and it doesn't sound like anyone did.
The national media may focus on the racial comments, but locally, this looks like what Ratto described it as being: a pure Giants power play to quash dissent on "their" station.
Exactly, bear88,
I'm surprised they fired him
by miguel on Aug 10, 2005 9:49 AM PDT reply actions
and earned his salary
by gigglingone on Aug 10, 2005 10:01 AM PDT up reply actions
on that note
by Alien @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 10:01 AM PDT up reply actions
But
Fresno #1- one fast ball
Slow walk out
Fresno #2- Curve ball
Slow walk out
Fresno #3- slider
Slow walk out
Fresno #4- Change up
Slow walk out
Hawkins- Fast ball down the middle jacked
Alou's head explodes, the Giants lose.
BTW- this story made the front page of the papers, where their loss to the Braves was on page 7. Got to love Gnats Baseball!
Ah, but the key is
That's Hemingway waiting to happen...
by almostreggie on Aug 10, 2005 3:02 PM PDT up reply actions
Listening to Radnich....
It's bigger than that,...
SOunds like Agnew had to go cuz someone in managment had to be sacrificed, and unfortunately he was the line manager that was closest to the situation.
Business.
by BleacherDave on Aug 10, 2005 10:09 AM PDT up reply actions
KNBR could have prevented this...
Any station in this business should have an emergency plan for when something like this goes down...because you know it's going to happen sometime. Once an incident occurs, the station needs to be very clear with its employees about how it will be handled and discussed. This is especially true, given that these folks are, under normal circumstances, encouraged to be irreverent and provocative. If KNBR had made it clear to its employees that the Kreuger incident should not be made light of, this might have been avoided. And if KNBR did direct its employees in this manner, they disregarded that direction.
That's my point exactly
by gigglingone on Aug 10, 2005 10:04 AM PDT up reply actions
It probably
That would have been Agnew's job,
by reztips on Aug 10, 2005 11:09 AM PDT up reply actions
I woke up to KNBR this morning and heard the bomb
I'm Asian - I've lived in the melting pot of the East Bay my entire life - and I NEVER KNEW THAT!!!! Can anyone verify that?
by Kaybeejay on Aug 10, 2005 10:07 AM PDT reply actions
That's Cass...
by BleacherDave on Aug 10, 2005 10:10 AM PDT up reply actions
Yeah, she's a complete moron
How about when Bill PArcels said..
That's way more offensive that what Krueger did.
by Kaybeejay on Aug 10, 2005 11:37 AM PDT up reply actions
My wife...
And by the way...
My wife was born in the Caribbean....
by BleacherDave on Aug 10, 2005 10:17 AM PDT up reply actions
Bleacher Dave
by MychaelUrban on Aug 10, 2005 1:38 PM PDT up reply actions
The way Krueger used it it was offensive
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 10:22 AM PDT up reply actions
So he was trying to get fired?
Of course not
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 10:38 AM PDT up reply actions
Some are saying that
Royal Caribbean Cruise Lines is changing its name to West Indies Funships.
by Checkswing HR on Aug 10, 2005 11:23 AM PDT up reply actions
I'm not sure about "well known"
The thing is, the "it was just a stupid mistake" argument would have more weight if Krueger had used "Latin" or some other common term instead of "Caribbean." At least in that case, the idea that he just flew off the handle and said something he didn't mean might hold some water. In this case, the use of the term Caribbean says to me that he thought about it, knew it would be offensive to use "Latin" or some other commonly understood ethnic term, and deliberately tried to use a not-as-racially charged substitute. Given the time/thought it takes to do that, you have to conclude he meant what he said.
Therefore, it's 100% appropriate that he's been fired from a mass media provider for denigrating an ethnic group on the air.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 11:46 AM PDT up reply actions
If,
It's clearly a double standard. If I obliquely referred to Erstad and Ellis as "brain-dead Dakotan infielders," nobody would be inferring these wild hidden meanings, for the simple reason that THAT'S WHERE THEY'RE FROM and, of course, because Ellis and Erstad are white.
by Checkswing HR on Aug 10, 2005 12:13 PM PDT up reply actions
It may be a double standard,
There are plenty of ways to call out Cruz and Feliz without using a thinly vieled euphemism for Latino (how about "I think we know who I'm talking about here"). Krueger knew that too.
Krueger chose his words pretty carefully here, and his message came across loud and clear.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 1:14 PM PDT up reply actions
In this situation
by Alien @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 1:17 PM PDT up reply actions
Exactly and that represents
Doesn't the Caribbean include
And doesn't the Caribbean consist of a bunch of islands, hence "can't walk off the island"? Nobody uses "Caribbean" to refer to Mexicans or Venezuelans or Panamanians.
by floyd on Aug 10, 2005 6:58 PM PDT up reply actions
krueger interview
http://nbxsportshow.com/broadcast/?media=16467.mp3
by dj4roy on Aug 10, 2005 10:30 AM PDT reply actions
Serious Conflict Of Interest
by bayfrank on Aug 10, 2005 10:51 AM PDT reply actions
A real disgrace
Almost nobody really even knew Krueger's comments were that bad until Alou went insane. And the morning show bit had it on the mark. "Messenger of Satan"? He's out of his mind.
All that said, the truth is in the posting above. It's all about the guys at corporate and the sale of the station.
Radnich is not liking the Giants right now. He just referred to Krukow's morning bit as stupid drivel. And he just tore off a terrific insult at Barry.
Rick and Rod will have nothing of interest to say about this.
What will Barbieri do? He had a fairly eloquent defense of Krueger yesterday. (Disclaimer: I hate Barbieri.) Easy prediction: Barbieri will blame it in large part on the national media that covered the story. He won't blame the station; he won't blame Alou; he won't blame the Giants; he won't blame Krueger. He'll stupidly blame the messenger.
What a bunch of braindead idiots. Too bad this will all blow over and the station will get back to ass-kissing business as usual.
I've got new respect...
by BleacherDave on Aug 10, 2005 11:58 AM PDT up reply actions
Braindead
This highlights the Giants circus
- Sabean built an old team around a 40+ year old jerk, who is now injured and may decide to not show up in a Giants uniform ever again.
- The new stadium draws fans who would be better suited for watching the latest flick at the Metreon.
- Giants lose games repeatedly and management distracts fans by continually unveiling statues of former players. Note: most fans have little idea who these players were.
- Krueger, an intelligent baseball guy torn by his allegiance to KNBR and the Giants, snaps from watching this Giants monstrosity -- and actually becomes critical of Alou's poor management and the ineptitude of the Giants management.
by Berkeley Steve on Aug 10, 2005 11:26 AM PDT reply actions
In fact...
by Berkeley Steve on Aug 10, 2005 11:34 AM PDT up reply actions
If Krueger called Alou Satan,
Instead, Alou says Krueger is Satan, and Alou is held up like a freaking Civil Rights hero.
What an irony. Making fun of the "Satan" remark is treated more harshly than the Satan remark itself, which, more accurately described, receives no retribution.
Alou should be fired for destroying three men's careers, which come to think of it, is a worse offense than a single adverb in a four-hour radio program.
BTW, journalists are supposed to present both sides of a story. I learned that in High School journalism class, for crying out loud. I have yet to see ESPN et al quote people who are willing to defend Krueger.
by Checkswing HR on Aug 10, 2005 11:43 AM PDT reply actions
What is there to defend?
Sometimes the sky is just blue, and there is no need for a counter-argument. This is one of those cases.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 11:48 AM PDT up reply actions
Dick Williams: Many "other sides"
That's my story and I'm sticking to it
And for the record, I'm not talking about Alou's Satan stuff or any other tangential issue. As for Krueger, he fired a racial salvo, KNBR were well within their rights to fire him for it, and they did so. End of story.
This isn't a high horse thing - although I appreciate the ad hominem barb - it's just clarity. There is a lot of stuff swirling around the central issue here that obfuscates the otherwise obvious.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 12:28 PM PDT up reply actions
Uninformed
Simply put he made a racial comment that, in my personal informed opinion, wasn't motivated by racism. And yes there is a difference.
by rcb on Aug 10, 2005 12:52 PM PDT up reply actions
OK...
That argument holds no water. I'm sorry. The only reason to bring up ethnicity is to find fault with it. Mission accomplished.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 12:59 PM PDT up reply actions
Due to the mantra
And if you didn't catch it, I did say it was a bad choice to generalize in that manner and that I didn't think it had racist undertones.
by rcb on Aug 10, 2005 1:14 PM PDT up reply actions
Alou grossly overreacted
A better punishment
by southofcruiseamerica on Aug 10, 2005 11:52 AM PDT reply actions
Big Money
I heard a national radio guy talk about how some teams absolutely forbid criticism of the team and its employees on their flagship station. I used to think that's what the Giants were doing here; were using this incident to make an example of Larry to restrict criticism of the team on KNBR. I'm sure the Giants are happy to see Krueger go, especially since they don't have to be the heavy. The Giants benefit, they have a critical voice off the air at an important renewal time for their season ticket base, but they're gonna get some backlash. I think they would have preferred that a chastened Larry Krueger stayed on the air. A neutered Krueger would have been an ongoing symbol to not mess with the Giants. Who knows who they get as a replacement?
Will KNBR feel a need to hire a critical voice in order to maintain the perception of their integrity? Somehow, I doubt it.
Lost in all of this...
by tettleton @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 12:28 PM PDT reply actions
There it is!
The problem is that there is a stereotype that Latinos aren't as smart, and therefore are more likely to do dumb things, like swing at obviously bad pitches. Krueger bought into the dumb stereotype, and communicated it on the air. That he used the term Caribbean only points to the deliberate - not knee jerk - nature of making the comment.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 12:38 PM PDT up reply actions
Re
Not everyone will agree on what is prejudiced or not, but I think Kruegers comment (the "braindead" one, not the COW one which meant nothing) clearly would offend some people. I'm not a particularly sensitive person, but the last thing I'd want to hear on the air is "So-and-so is holding out for more money", the response being (in jest) "Well, he is Jewish".
Look, I don't know whether or not Krueger should have been fired, but I don't think you could ever say that his comments weren't that offensive, especially if you are not a member of the nationality called into question.
by Alien @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 1:00 PM PDT up reply actions
The only stereotyping committed
by rcb on Aug 10, 2005 1:06 PM PDT up reply actions
I don't see where you get that
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 1:17 PM PDT up reply actions
But the complete phrase was . . .
by rcb on Aug 10, 2005 1:26 PM PDT up reply actions
rcb
Open your eyes when you read my posts
And yes, you are selectively editing when you only refer to the phrase "brain dead Caribbeans".
by rcb on Aug 10, 2005 2:16 PM PDT up reply actions
I think the point
Wait a second
by Alien @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 2:45 PM PDT up reply actions
Alien:
My personal view
Nico, you are bright enough to see that Krueger probably didn't mean that all Caribbeans are brain dead. Unfortunately, the public at-large is generally not. As I said previously, when you've got a job like Krueger's, you've got to be very careful not to perpetuate stereotypes. Maybe this limits free speech, maybe its too "PC", but in a country that is so sensitive to racism, I think its important to try and keep ethnicity "out of it" whenever possible. The fact that so many people DID link "braindead" and "Caribbean" together illustrates how quickly people make those connections.
by Alien @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 3:03 PM PDT up reply actions
Yes, but if Krueger
But then I'm not all that impressed with "the American public."
Also, in an attempt to make a joke that relies on the next post being the one I think it will be:
"N-81...N-81."
I don't get it
I hope not, I've always thought they smell bad.
by Alien @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 3:16 PM PDT up reply actions
If you want to disect this further . . .
I am officially exhausted of this topic.
by rcb on Aug 10, 2005 3:10 PM PDT up reply actions
Yes, I'm sick of it too
Why are we talking about this again?
by Alien @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 3:14 PM PDT up reply actions
Disagree
Krueger's deliberate choice of the euphemism "Caribbean" shows that he was aware of the incendiary nature of his statement, but chose to make it anyway. That deliberate, thought-out choice shows intent to disparage.
Believe me, I recognize that Alou is being held to a different standard, and that the PC police go overboard a lot of the time, but in this case, looking at the facts we have in front of us, this guy meant what he said, and what he said was racist.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 2:51 PM PDT up reply actions
Krueger deserved it
Why doesn't Ray Ratto work for KNBR
Seriously though, do we really want Satan to have a nightly radio show?
by Bearcat on Aug 10, 2005 2:43 PM PDT reply actions
Braindead hitters, not Braindead Caribbeans
Yes, that is a racial think to say. I've always thought what he said was racist, but I've also thought it wasn't very serious. In a way, Alou himself is making a racial judgment about such players, as is the entire national media, in how they are typically characterized. Krueger just ran with that and called that style of play, that baseball mentality, "braindead."
And please, "Dick Williams," don't cite Bobby Abreu to make an argument--isn't that simpleminded and anecdotal? Really, one worthwhile thing that could emerge from this nonsense would be to examine whether Alou, Krueger, and so many other people are right or wrong in their characterization of such hitters as a group. Because, you see, Alou's right their with Krueger--Krueger just said it was braindead.
And, finally, the sort of racist impulse Krueger and Alou and so many others easily fall victim to is all around us in sports.
Quick, if I say a player is a thug, what color is his skin? What if I say he works very hard without a lot of talent? What if I say he's a lunch-bucket guy? Or scrappy? If I say an NFL receiver has pure athletic talent and speed--what color is he? If I say the guy that lines up opposite him runs precise patterns, what color is he?
Huh?
Manny Ramirez
David Ortiz
Luis Castillo
Melvin Mora
Raoul Ibanez
Felipe Lopez
Also, I must have missed where Alou characterized Latin players the same way, but I haven't paid a lot of attention to what Alou has said.
I think we all agree the stereotypes you mention are a problem. What I'm saying is that Krueger's comments served to perpetuate those stereotypes, and did so in a particularly egregious way. That he was fired from a position in mass media is therefore completely deserved and not at all surprising.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 3:07 PM PDT up reply actions
Mr. Dick Williams
by tettleton @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 3:45 PM PDT up reply actions
Because
by tettleton @ Athletics Nation on Aug 10, 2005 4:05 PM PDT up reply actions
I'm not saying you need to be offended
In this case though, I really do see an intent to denigrate Latinos, so that offends me as a human being, and it pisses me off. I'm really surprised that others don't see the intent, because the nature of the statement seems to speak directly to an intent to denigrate. The choice of words and euphemisms says to me that it was a deliberate statement, and not a knee-jerk accident. Again, I'm really surprised that this isn't obvious to everyone.
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 4:26 PM PDT up reply actions
the only thing that's obvious
So the only conclusion I'm making from this is that this is just yet another example of why miscommunication is so rampant: people getting fired up and taking drastic actions in response to an issue that they haven't even bothered to precisely define, or may be even incapable of precisely defining. But if they're incapable of precisely defining it, and they're surrounded by people who are similarly incapable, something tells me that the thought may never occur to them that they are incapable. Self-awareness sure isn't as rampant as miscommunication. And initial impressions, often emotionally charged, are often tempting to run with, but that's irresponsible. Add in a tangled web of conflicting agendas...
Ah the futility of human affairs.
by Cutthemullet on Aug 11, 2005 1:50 AM PDT up reply actions
see, this is why I'm drawn to sports
Logically, then, I think it is true that all this is not truth, but it is not true that I know that it is true that all this is not true.
by Cutthemullet on Aug 11, 2005 3:07 AM PDT up reply actions
Best. Post. Ever.
We've got some bright minds on this site, folks.
by Checkswing HR on Aug 11, 2005 11:31 AM PDT up reply actions
Dick,
by Checkswing HR on Aug 10, 2005 4:29 PM PDT up reply actions
Too hypothetical
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 5:00 PM PDT up reply actions
Well, either that or Alou
Remember...
by DickWilliams on Aug 10, 2005 5:10 PM PDT up reply actions
On that, I'd have to defer,
Nico, since you are apart of the governing group
Seems totally reasonable to me
Are all announcers tongue tied lately
Diamondbacks television analyst Mark Grace used multiple expletives during a broadcast of Arizona's game against the Florida Marlins.
f-bomb
by Bearcat on Aug 10, 2005 5:03 PM PDT up reply actions
That will be Kreugers appeal
by theblackpearl on Aug 10, 2005 7:42 PM PDT up reply actions
The Orioles are coming to play us on Monday
But to really get to him, we could use that terrible, terrible word:
"Pon-son is Ca-rib-be-an!"
by Checkswing HR on Aug 10, 2005 4:42 PM PDT reply actions
Ponson in Spanish is Ponzo
by pachydermOAFC on Aug 10, 2005 4:59 PM PDT up reply actions
Just heard Barbieri say
So, essentially, Krueger got fired because his colleagues made fun of Alou's absurd Satan comments. KNBR management is a bunch of weak-ass panderers that treat their employees like cattle, and can't take a stand on anything. Unless it benefits their bottom line.
I listen to kmel..
by AllThingsOakland on Aug 10, 2005 5:22 PM PDT up reply actions
I do too now that Chuey is in the mornings.
by theblackpearl on Aug 10, 2005 7:42 PM PDT up reply actions
Hearing the explanations
But what strikes me, after listening to KNBR and reading the papers, is the desperate effort to distance the Giants from all of this.
The Giants, we are told, didn't demand that Krueger be fired. Shoot, even Alou wasn't demanding that. It was all just an unlucky "confluence of events" - the Krueger comment, the morning show bit, the station sale, et cetera.
I do not like it when someone insults my intelligence.
The only reason the morning show sketch would have prompted anything is that KNBR management would have worried that Alou was going to use it to renew his attacks on the station, keeping the issue in the news.
Last I checked, Felipe Alou is a Giants employee. The Giants could have told him to pipe down, that he had made his point already. But they wouldn't or did not believe he would listen to them.
Alou and the Giants are being disingenuous. Right now, he (and the team) should be saying: "Good. A racist was fired, and I'm glad." Instead, he and the Giants are dancing away from the whole thing, claiming they had nothing to do with it. KNBR is telling the same story, but it doesn't hold up even if you believe their version of events.
The truth? Alou wanted Krueger fired. That's what the whole "messenger of Satan" thing on ESPN was about. It was to turn up the heat, as was his decision not to accept Krueger's apology or meet with him. The Giants wanted him gone too, both to support Alou and because he was an inconvenient dissenting voice (tolerable when he was bashing Dusty Baker, but not now).
The Giants are entitled to throw their weight around and dictate what happens on their flagship station. They don't get to avoid responsibility. These people were fired because of the Giants, period.

by 























